London, 07 April 2011 -- Moody's Investors Service says today that over the next few weeks,
it will begin a reassessment of the systemic support assumptions that
it currently incorporates into its senior debt ratings for UK financial
institutions. This follows on from Moody's announcement on
March 24th of a reassessment of support assumptions for smaller European
financial institutions.
The reassessment announced today in the UK will focus on the high systemic
support assumptions currently incorporated in the senior debt ratings
of small to medium-sized UK financial institutions, as well
as, on a case-by-case basis, the level of systemic
support incorporated in the large, complex financial institutions.
Moody's includes systemic support in the ratings of nineteen UK
financial institutions, with 1-5 notches in the senior debt
ratings. This reassessment could trigger negative outlooks ,
reviews for possible downgrade, or downgrades for some ratings and
will be taking into consideration Moody's expectations on how the
relevant banks' standalone credit strength will develop.
RATIONALE FOR THE REASSESSMENT
The key driver for Moody's reassessment in the UK is the large number
of financial institutions, particularly small to medium-sized
firms, that have high levels of support in their ratings and which,
in Moody's view, are unlikely to be deemed "systemic"
over the medium term. There are currently significantly higher
levels of systemic support incorporated in the senior debt ratings of
UK financial institutions than was the case pre-crisis.
UK banks benefit from up to five notches of uplift in the senior debt
ratings, whereas the pre-crisis levels of support were typically
0 -- 1 notches for the small to medium-sized banks and two
notches for the largest banks. Moody's has stated in several
of its publications that it intends to phase-out this 'extraordinary'
support from its senior debt ratings of UK banks. Most recently,
Moody's announced a systematic reassessment of support assumptions
for smaller European financial institutions (see "Moody's
Reassesses Systemic Support for Senior Debt of Smaller European Financial
Institutions: Spanish Bank Ratings Downgraded as a First Step",
24 March 2011).
The reassessment is not driven by either a deterioration in the financial
strength of the banking system or that of the government. It has
been initiated against the background of ongoing guidance from the UK
Tripartite authorities (the Bank of England, the Financial Services
Authority and the Treasury) that banks that fail in the future should
not expect capital injections from the public purse. The authorities
have taken a number of legislative and other steps to permit losses to
be imposed on creditors as part of the going-concern resolution
of banks.
Equally, the UK authorities have made it clear that they do not
view the banking sector as a "zero failure" system.
Statements suggest a clear recognition that the need to avoid providing
taxpayer money to banks in future should be balanced against the need
to maintain financial stability. The authorities have made clear
that the current resolution tools (namely, the 2009 Banking Act)
are only suitable for the resolution of small to medium-sized banks,
but that they will continue to work with European and international bodies
to address the resolvability of large, complex banks. Moody's
will therefore continue to assume some systemic support for the major
UK institutions, at least pending greater clarity around the development
of the resolution framework in Europe and elsewhere.
TIMEFRAME FOR REASSESSMENT
Consequently, and following on from its announcement on 24 March,
within the next few weeks Moody's will begin reassessing what it
considers to be the appropriate level of systemic support in the senior
debt ratings. If this leads to ratings being placed under review
for possible downgrade, then the review process could take up to
three months. At the same time, if Moody's also identifies
upward pressure on the standalone ratings of some banks --
which could offset or mitigate some of the downward pressure on the senior
debt ratings -- the rating agency will also review these
standalone ratings during that period.
POTENTIAL IMPACT ON LARGE, COMPLEX BANKS
As indicated in the March 2010 announcement, (see "Phasing
out Extraordinary Support Assumptions from UK Bank Ratings",
March 2010) Moody's intends, for now at least, to continue
to assume some level of systemic support for senior debt issued by larger
financial institutions. Pre-crisis, such support assumptions
accounted for an average of two notches of rating uplift. Moody's
expects to be able to make a more informed assessment of this in the second
half of 2011, once there is greater clarity regarding the treatment
of SIFIs (Systemically Important Financial Institutions) and future resolution
mechanisms within Europe.
In the meantime, negative outlooks will be used, where appropriate,
to indicate the medium-term pressure on some of these senior debt
ratings as a consequence of proposed changes to resolution frameworks.
In addition, the rating agency will, as announced, continue
to assess the support likely to be available to any financial institution
(large or small) on a case-by-case basis, where the
probability of the authorities being able and willing to resolve problems
through means other than financial support appears to be increasing.
The case-by-case assessments will be particularly relevant
for those large banks in the UK which currently have very high levels
of crisis support incorporated in the senior debt ratings. This
refers to the levels introduced to reflect the 'extraordinary'
support provided during the crisis and which far exceed levels assumed
pre-crisis.
The rating agency's assessment will reflect the medium-term
time horizon of our ratings, and will take account of: (i)
the strong willingness of the UK authorities to improve the resolvability
of large banks over the medium term; (ii) the level of government
capital received by some banks and the timeframe for the government to
exit these investments over the same horizon; (iii) the need to reflect
the changing environment by returning at some point to pre-crisis
levels of support in our ratings; and (iv) the direction of the Independent
Commission on Banking (ICB), which is reviewing structural changes
to the banking system that are expected to have the greatest impact on
the large banks. The ICB will outline an interim proposal on 11
April. As mentioned above, Moody's would also balance
these factors against the timeframe for the potential recovery of the
standalone financial strength ratings of the banks.
Financial institutions covered by this reassessment are as follows:
Bank of Ireland (UK) plc; Bank of Scotland plc; Barclays Bank
plc; Clydesdale Bank plc; Co-Operative Bank plc;
Coventry Building Society; HSBC Holdings plc; HSBC Bank plc;
Lloyds Banking Group; Nationwide Building Society; Newcastle
Building Society; Norwich & Peterborough Building Society;
Nottingham Building Society; Principality Building Society;
Royal Bank of Scotland Group; Santander UK plc; Skipton Building
Society; West Bromwich Building Society; Yorkshire Building
Society;
London
Elisabeth Rudman
VP - Senior Credit Officer
Financial Institutions Group
Moody's Investors Service Ltd.
JOURNALISTS: 44 20 7772 5456
SUBSCRIBERS: 44 20 7772 5454
London
Johannes Wassenberg
MD - Banking
Financial Institutions Group
Moody's Investors Service Ltd.
JOURNALISTS: 44 20 7772 5456
SUBSCRIBERS: 44 20 7772 5454
Moody's Investors Service Ltd.
One Canada Square
Canary Wharf
London E14 5FA
United Kingdom
JOURNALISTS: 44 20 7772 5456
SUBSCRIBERS: 44 20 7772 5454
Moody's to reassess systemic support for UK financial institutions