MOODY'S DOWNGRADES CARNIVAL'S LONG-TERM RATING TO A3, AND ITS SHORT-TERM RATING TO PRIME-2, AND LEAVES ITS RATINGS ON REVIEW FOR POSSIBLE DOWNGRADE, AND LEAVES P&O PRINCESS plc's RATINGS ON REVIEW FOR POSSIBLE UPGRADE.
Approximately $5.6 billion of debt affected.
New York, April 14, 2003 -- Moody's Investors Service downgraded the long-term ratings
of Carnival Corporation (Carnival) to A3 from A2, and its short-term
rating to Prime-2 from Prime-1 to reflect its expected combination
with P&O Princess Cruises, plc (P&O). The long-term
ratings of Carnival Corporation remain on review for further possible
downgrade pending final resolution of the combined group's capital structure,
and the ratings for P&O remain on review for possible upgrade.
The downgrade of Carnival's ratings reflects Moody's expectation
that:
(1) The combination of P&O and Carnival will result in increased proforma
leverage.
(2) Continued company and industry-wide capacity expansion will
continue to pressure Carnival's earnings and cash flow, given
that it is occurring at a time when net revenue yields and margins are
already challenged as a result of new capacity, a soft economy,
concerns related to terrorism and the war in Iraq, and cost increases.
(3) Carnival will generate negative free cash flow in 2003 and 2004 as
a result of the significant committed capital spending program for both
Carnival and P&O brands.
(4) Carnival's net borrowing needs could increase if booking volumes
fail to keep pace with capacity expansion.
Carnival's long-term ratings remain on review for further
possible downgrade, while P&O's ratings remain on review
for possible upgrade, pending final resolution of the combined group's
capital structure. The ongoing review will focus on the degree
of effective and structural subordination in the capital structure,
including the implications of the cross-guarantees that are required
for new, but not existing, lenders. A further downgrade,
if any, of Carnival's ratings would be modest. The
company's ratings could be confirmed if the level of subordination
does not impair the position of unsecured creditors, and if existing
bondholders are not disadvantaged by the cross-guarantees envisaged
for new lenders.
P&O's ratings remain on review for possible upgrade also pending
final resolution of the combined group's capital structure.
The review of P&O's ratings will focus on the degree of effective
subordination in P&O's capital structure, P&O's
strategic role in the combined group, as well as the implications
of the cross-guarantees that are required for new, but not
existing, lenders.
The downgrade of Carnival's ratings to A3, and Prime-2 reflects
the continuing downward pressure on cruise pricing that first began in
2000, and was significantly impacted by the events of September
11, 2001. Pricing on a per available lower berth day basis
remains well below the peak levels achieved in 1999, and capacity
expansion, economic weakness, and geopolitical risks continue
to exert downward pressure on net revenue yields. This environment
increases the risk that the combined entity's borrowing needs may
be higher than anticipated and could cause credit statistics to deteriorate.
Both Carnival and P&O have reduced costs on a per available lower
berth day basis, which has helped to mitigate the decline in margins,
but recent increases in fuel and insurance costs are expected to put downward
pressure on margins. Moody's has incorporated the positive
aspects of Carnival's combination with P&O into its ratings,
including the addition of complementary well-known brands,
acceleration of Carnival's expansion outside North America,
and potential cost synergies. The combination with P&O will
also lead to improved geographic diversification, and reduces the
average age of Carnival's fleet. Moody's also considers
Carnival's relatively conservative financial policies, and
strong management team to be a credit positive.
Moody's notes that on a combined entity basis, 2002 proforma
retained cash flow to total adjusted debt was approximately 27%,
and total coverage was 7.6x. Together Carnival and P&O
have 17 ships on order for delivery through 2006. The combined
entity will be a net borrower in 2003 and 2004, as internally generated
cash will not be sufficient to finance total capital and dividend needs.
Moody's estimates that the combined entity can finance between 60%-70%
of its total capital, and dividend requirements from internally
generated cash flow over the next two years.
Carnival currently has secured debt of about $121 million on one
ship, and debt at subsidiaries of approximately $1.0
billion. P&O currently has approximately $1.4
billion of secured debt, and has commitments of about $1.0
billion to finance up to three new ship deliveries with secured debt.
Both Carnival and P&O have sufficient liquidity in the form of committed
financing to meet their respective cash needs. Carnival maintains
revolving credit facilities of $1.65 billion that mature
in June 2006, and currently has cash balances totaling about $710
million. P&O has committed lines of credit of $435 million
that mature in September 2005, and undrawn committed secured financing
facilities of $1.0 billion. Neither company has significant
debt maturities in 2003 or 2004. However, Carnival's
convertible debt issues are puttable in 2005, and 2006.
The merger of Carnival and P&O under a dual listed company structure
has been approved by Carnival's shareholders at a special board meeting
held on 4/14/03, and is expected to be approved by shareholders
of P&O at a special board meeting scheduled to take place on April
16, 2003. A dual listed company structure will allow the
two companies to effectively merge while remaining as separate legal,
and publicly listed entities. This will be accomplished through
a series of agreements that equalizes the voting and economic interests
of shareholders of each company, and established corporate governance
procedures. Carnival has offered to purchase each P&O Princess
share in exchange for Carnival stock for a total value of approximately
$5.5 billion based upon Carnival's recent stock price.
Ratings downgraded:
Commercial paper to Prime-2 from Prime-1.
Ratings downgraded, and that remain on review for possible downgrade:
Carnival Corporation
Senior unsecured notes, debentures, and convertible notes
to A3 from A2.
Senior unsecured shelf registration to (P) A3 from (P) A2.
Subordinated shelf registration to (P) Baa1 from (P) A3.
Preferred stock shelf registration to (P) Baa2 from (P) Baa1.
Costa Finance S.A.
Senior unsecured Euro notes, guaranteed by Carnival Corporation
to A3 from A2.
Ratings that remain on review for possible upgrade:
P&O Princess Cruises plc
Senior unsecured notes guaranteed by P&O Cruises Limited at Baa3
Carnival Corporation, headquartered in Miami, Florida and
its subsidiaries operate six brands under the names, Carnival Cruise
Lines, Holland America Line, Costa, Windstar Cruises,
Cunard Line and Seabourn Cruise Line. During the year ended November
30, 2002, Carnival's revenues were approximately $4.4
billion. P&O Princess Cruises plc and its subsidiaries operates
seven brands under the names, Princess, P&O Cruises (UK),
Ocean Village, Swan Hellenic, AROSA, AIDA Cruises,
and P&O Cruises (Australia). During the year ended December
31, 2002, P&O's revenues were approximately $2.6
billion.
New York
Angela Jameson
Managing Director
Industrial
Moody's Investors Service
JOURNALISTS: 212-553-0376
SUBSCRIBERS: 212-553-1653
New York
Peggy Holloway
VP - Senior Credit Officer
Industrial
Moody's Investors Service
JOURNALISTS: 212-553-0376
SUBSCRIBERS: 212-553-1653