Tokyo, July 29, 2009 -- Moody's Investors Service announced today that it has downgraded to Aa1
from Aaa the Class 3 trust certificates of the Tokyo Metropolitan CLO
Ninth transaction. The trust certificates had been under review
for possible downgrade since May 19, 2009. At the same time,
Moody's says that it has affirmed the ratings of all other outstanding
classes of the following Japanese regional government-related SME
CLO transactions:
- Tokyo Supporters CLO Special Purpose Company,
- Ordinance-Designated Cities CLO Fourth,
- Santoshi CLO2009,
- Yontoshi CLO2 Tokutei Mokuteki Kaisha,
- Santoshi CLO 2009 Tokutei Mokuteki Kaisha, and
- Class 1A, 1B, 1C and 2 of Tokyo Metropolitan CLO
Ninth
These transactions are CLO backed by corporate loans extended to SMEs.
Their underlying loans are either fully guaranteed (Tokyo Supporters CLO
Special Purpose Company only), or 80% guaranteed by the Credit
Guarantee Corporation ("CGC") on a loan-by-loan basis.
Under the credit insurance system, the guarantee obligation of CGC
is insured by the Japan Finance Corporation ("JFC") to as much as 70-80%
of the guaranteed amount. The relevant regional governments compensate
those CGC guarantee obligations which exceed JFC's insured amounts.
Specified Bonds issued by Yontoshi CLO2 Tokutei Mokuteki Kaisha is backed
by Class 1 trust certificates issued under Tokyo Metropolitan CLO Ninth
and Ordinance-Designated Cities CLO Fourth. Specified Bonds
issued by Santoshi CLO 2009 Tokutei Mokuteki Kaisha is backed by Class
1 trust certificates issued under Santoshi CLO2009.
Moody's says that today's rating actions reflect the rating actions taken
against Metropolis of Tokyo, Osaka City Government, and JFC.
On July 28, 2009, Metropolis of Tokyo and Osaka City Government
were downgraded to Aa2 from Aa1 (domestic currency), and on July
22, 2009, JFC was downgraded to Aa2 from Aaa. Metropolis
of Tokyo, Osaka City Government, and JFC had been under review
for possible downgrade since May 18, 2009. In conjunction
with the consideration of guarantor credit changes, Moody's also
considered the current underlying pool performance of each transaction.
Specifically, for Tokyo Supporters CLO, the actual default
rate was higher than our initial expected.
As described above, the ability of CGC to perform its guarantee
obligation strongly relies on the credit quality of the relevant regional
governments as well as JFC. However, the downgrade of their
ratings to Aa2 and the changes in the performance of the portfolios only
has a limited impact on all Aaa ratings except for the Class 3 of Tokyo
Metropolitan CLO Ninth Transaction, hence those ratings are affirmed.
On the other hand, for Class 3 of Tokyo Metropolitan CLO Ninth,
the credit enhancement is not sufficient to support a Aaa rating relative
to the current stressed loss rate in combination with the consideration
of guarantor's current credit assessment. As a result, the
rating of the trust certificates was downgraded to Aa1 from Aaa.
At the same time, for Class 3 of same series (Ordinance-Designated
Cities CLO Fourth and Santoshi CLO2009), its Aa1 ratings were affirmed.
The principal methodologies used in rating these transactions were "Japan's
SME CDOs: Focal Points in Rating Analysis and Monitoring,"
"Repackaged Securities (October 2001)," and "Moody's Refines Its
Approach to Rating Structured Notes (July 1997)," which can be found
at www.moodys.com in the Credit Policy & Methodologies
directory, in the Ratings Methodologies subdirectory. Other
methodologies and factors that may have been considered in the process
of rating this issue can also be found in the Credit Policy & Methodologies
directory.
Today's rating actions follow:
Tokyo Supporters CLO Special Purpose Company:
(1) Series 1 Class B JPY13,800,000,000 Specified Bonds
due November 2010, Aaa affirmed; previously on March 9,
2005, assigned Aaa
(2) Series 1 Class C JPY4,300,000,000 Specified Bonds
due November 2010, Aaa affirmed; previously on October 11,
2007, upgraded to Aaa from Aa1
Tokyo Metropolitan CLO Ninth:
(3) Class 1A JPY753,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(4) Class 1B JPY753,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(5) Class 1C JPY753,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(6) Class 2 JPY16,768,000,000 Trust Certificates,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(7) Class 3 JPY8,684,000,000 Trust Certificates,
Downgraded to Aa1 from Aaa; previously on May 19, 2009,
Aaa placed under review for possible downgrade
Ordinance-Designated Cities CLO Fourth:
(8) Class 1A JPY247,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(9) Class 1B JPY247,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(10) Class 1C JPY247,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(11) Class 2 JPY7,885,000,000 Trust Certificates,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(12) Class 3 JPY3,971,000,000 Trust Certificates,
Aa1 affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aa1
Santoshi CLO2009:
(13) Class 1A JPY200,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned Aaa
(14) Class 1B JPY200,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned Aaa
(15) Class 1C JPY200,000,000 Trust Certificates, Aaa
affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned Aaa
(16) Class 2 JPY5,085,000,000 Trust Certificates,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned
Aaa
(17) Class 3 JPY3,902,000,000 Trust Certificates,
Aa1 affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned
Aa1
Yontoshi CLO2 Tokutei Mokuteki Kaisha:
(18) Series 1 Class A JPY1,000,000,000 Specified Bonds,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(19) Series 1 Class B JPY1,000,000,000 Specified Bonds,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
(20) Series 1 Class C JPY1,000,000,000 Specified Bonds,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 4, 2008, assigned Aaa
Santoshi CLO 2009 Tokutei Mokuteki Kaisha:
(21) Series 1 Class A JPY 200,000,000 Specified Bonds,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned
Aaa
(22) Series 1 Class B JPY 200,000,000 Specified Bonds,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned
Aaa
(23) Series 1 Class C JPY 200,000,000 Specified Bonds,
Aaa affirmed; previously on March 12, 2009, assigned
Aaa
Moody's Investors Service is a publisher of rating opinions and research.
It is not involved in the offering or sale of any securities, nor
is it acting on behalf of the offering party. This release is not
a solicitation or a recommendation to buy, hold, or sell securities.
Tokyo
Shinji Yoshizawa
Analyst
Structured Finance Group
Moody's Japan K.K.
JOURNALISTS: (03) 5408-4110
SUBSCRIBERS: (03) 5408-4100
New York
Jian Hu
Managing Director
Structured Finance Group
Moody's Investors Service
JOURNALISTS: 212-553-0376
SUBSCRIBERS: 212-553-1653
Moody's downgrades Aaa rating of one class and affirms all other ratings from Japan regional government SME CLOs