London, 18 October 2010 -- Moody's Investors Service announced today that it had placed on review
for possible upgrade the insurance financial strength rating (A1) and
debt ratings (A2 senior, A3 subordinated, Baa1 preferred)
of Zurich Insurance Company Ltd (ZIC), and associated ratings listed
below.
The rating agency said that the rating review follows the improvement
in the credit profile of the Zurich Group (Zurich), especially with
regard to capital adequacy, financial flexibility, high risk
assets, and business diversification, whilst producing very
good operating performance in recent times and maintaining an excellent
market position.
The Group's solvency position has improved meaningfully in recent
times on both an economic and statutory basis. Its economic solvency
ratio, which is calibrated at a 99.95% confidence
level, at H1 10 was estimated at 124% compared to an internal
target range of 110-120%, and it has also filed with
the Swiss regulator a Swiss Solvency Test (SST) ratio in excess of 200%.
The Group's financial flexibility has also improved. YE09
adjusted financial leverage stood at 25%, marking a meaningful
decrease from the YE08 figure of 30%, primarily due to a
large increase in shareholders' equity. Total leverage also decreased
to 38% (YE08: 42%), and 2009 earnings cover
increased to 7.0x (YE08: 6.4x) with coverage on a
five year average basis very good at 8.4x. The Group's very
good access to capital markets was also demonstrated during 2009 by the
$1.1bn equity raise, and a number of senior and more
junior financial debt transactions. With regard to asset quality,
the proportion of high risk assets to equity decreased to 63% (YE08:
78%) with Zurich's investment portfolio viewed as relatively
conservative.
Notwithstanding difficult investment conditions, and losses from
non-core operations including Zurich Bank, Zurich's
recent return on capital (ROC) and business operating performance has
been very good. The Group's ROC for 2008 and 2009 was 8.5%
with an average from 2005-2009 of around 11.5%,
and on a Business Operating Profit (BOP) basis -- an internal measure
used by Zurich which indicates underlying performance- return on
equity for 2008 and 2009 was around 17% compared to a cross-cycle
target of 16%. Furthermore, Moody's sees a reduced
risk in the future of material losses emanating from the Group's
non-core activities.
Zurich's business profile remains excellent. It is a major
European insurance player with a strong market position in a broad range
of countries, including the U.S., and a strong
brand reach, although it lacks a top tier status in some important
European markets. Furthermore, the Group benefits from excellent
business and geographic diversification, and although the overall
business remains orientated towards P&C risk (67% of GWP and
policy fees at YE09) , the balance between life and non-life
is improving.
The rating agency said that its review for possible upgrade would concentrate
on the Group's ability to sustain the improvement in its credit
profile, and in particular on the Group's prospective economic
and regulatory capital and financial flexibility position, together
with cross-cycle profit potential. Moody's indicated
that in the event the review process resulted in an upgrade of Zurich's
ratings, such upgrade would highly likely be limited to one notch.
Moody's has also placed, inter alia, on review for possible
upgrade the ratings of the Group's UK and German Life subsidiaries,
Zurich Assurance Ltd (A2 IFSR) and Zurich Deutscher Herold Lebensverischerung
(A1 IFSR), together with the ratings of the Farmers Insurance Group
(A2 IFSR). These ratings all benefit to varying degrees from explicit
and/or implied support from Zurich. As part of its review process
Moody's will evaluate this support prospectively to help determine
whether these ratings should receive further uplift in the event of ZIC's
ratings being upgraded.
Additionally, Moody's affirmed with a stable outlook the A3
IFSR of Kemper Investors Life Insurance Company (KILICO). The rating
affirmation and stable outlook were driven by ZIC's continued support
of KILICO whose liabilities have been largely in runoff since 2003.
However, the large unrealized loss position on KILICO's USD10
bn BOLI (bank-owned life insurance) portfolio is very credit sensitive
and could lead to a greater dependence on parent resources in a stressed
economic environment.
The following ratings were placed on review for possible upgrade:
Zurich Insurance Company Ltd- A1 insurance financial strength rating;
Zurich Insurance Company Ltd and guaranteed EMTN issuers- A2 senior
unsecured debt, A3 subordinated debt, Baa1 capital note;
Zurich Insurance Company Ltd- (P) A3 and (P) Baa1 EMTN Programme
Type A Capital Notes, (P) Baa1 and (P) Baa2 EMTN Programme Type
B Capital Notes;
Zurich RegCaPS Funding Trust II, V & VI: Baa1 preferred
stock rating;
Zurich Finance (USA) Trusts I- V: Baa1 preferred stock rating;
Zurich Assurance Ltd: A2 insurance financial strength rating;
Zurich Deutscher Herold Lebensverischerung AG: A1 insurance financial
strength rating;
ZC Specialty Insurance Company: A2 insurance financial strength
rating;
Centre Reinsurance (US) Ltd: A2 insurance financial strength rating;
Zurich Capital Markets Inc: A1 issuer rating;
ZCM Matched Funding Corp: A1 Issuer rating;
Espial Ventures Limited: A1 senior secured debt rating;
Capstone Investments Limited: A1 senior secured debt rating;
Argus Ventures Limited: A1 senior secured debt rating;
Vista Investments Limited: A1 senior secured debt rating;
Farmers Insurance Exchange: A2 insurance financial strength rating,
Baa2 surplus notes;
Farmers Insurance Company of Oregon: A2 insurance financial strength
rating;
Truck Insurance Exchange: A2 insurance financial strength rating;
Fire Insurance Exchange: A2 insurance financial strength rating;
Farmers Exchange Capital: Baa2 surplus notes;
Zurich Bank: A1 long-term bank deposit rating, (P)A2
guaranteed senior debt EMTN programme rating
The following rating was affirmed with a stable outlook:
Kemper Investors Life Insurance Company: A3 insurance financial
strength rating.
The following ratings were affirmed:
ZCM Matched Funding Corp: P-1 short-term issuer rating;
Zurich Bank: P-1 short-term bank deposit rating,
D- (negative outlook) bank financial strength rating
Based in Zurich, Switzerland, Zurich Financial Services (ZFS)
reported gross written premiums and policy fees of USD 53.8 billion
and total equity of USD 34 billion as of December 31, 2009.
Moody's last rating action on ZIC occurred on 17 April 2009 when the ratings
were affirmed with a stable outlook.
The principal methodologies used in rating ZIC were Moody's Global
Rating Methodology for Property and Casualty Insurers and Moody's Global
Rating Methodology for Life Insurers, both published in May 2010
and available on www.moodys.com in the Rating Methodologies
sub-directory under the Research & Ratings tab. Other
methodologies and factors that may have been considered in the process
of rating this issuer can also be found in the Rating Methodologies sub-directory
on Moody's website.
London
Simon Harris
MD - Financial Institutions
Financial Institutions Group
Moody's Investors Service Ltd.
JOURNALISTS: 44 20 7772 5456
SUBSCRIBERS: 44 20 7772 5454
London
Dominic Simpson
VP - Senior Credit Officer
Financial Institutions Group
Moody's Investors Service Ltd.
JOURNALISTS: 44 20 7772 5456
SUBSCRIBERS: 44 20 7772 5454
Moody's Investors Service Ltd.
One Canada Square
Canary Wharf
London E14 5FA
United Kingdom
Moody's places Zurich Insurance Company ratings (A1 IFSR) on review for possible upgrade