Hong Kong, December 31, 2009 -- Moody's Investors Service says that its ratings for Korean banks are likely
to remain unchanged despite the large exposures of some of these institutions
to the troubled Kumho Asiana Group, which is now poised for restructuring.
In addition, while Moody's is aware that most banks in Korea,
including those rated by Moody's, have some exposure to Kumho
Asiana members, we currently have only aggregate numbers and lack
a detailed breakdown of exposures by obligor and product type.
Furthermore, we can not say how much time will be required to liquidate
the group's assets, or how the share-purchase program
of the Korean Development Bank (KDB) -- the largest creditor --
will work.
"Although the exact details are unclear at this early stage,
we believe our existing bank ratings capture the risks, for three
reasons," said Moody's Vice President and Senior Analyst,
Youngil Choi.
First, the total exposures at most private sector banks could be
written off against 2009 earnings. Those that exceed earnings,
represent small proportions of capital.
Second, not all of its KRW 15.7 trillion of exposure (USD
13.6 bn) would require significant provisioning, as not all
members of Kumho Asiana -- Korea's 9th largest business
conglomerate or Jaebeol -- will be subject to the restructuring
announced yesterday.
And third, the Korean banks could write off all of their Kumho Asiana
exposures and still record lower losses than those assumed in our May
2009 downgrades of the Korean, due to the current global recession.
So far, the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) puts the credit
exposures of financial institutions to Kumho Asiana at KRW15.7
trillion -- KRW10.1 trillion in loans, KRW1.2
trillion in debt securities, and KRW 4.4 trillion in other
instruments.
But, the ultimate loss to Korea's banking sector could well
exceed the FSS estimate on the banks' credit loss provisioning of
KRW1.2 trillion, if the group's restructuring plan
does not play out smoothly.
In the long term, as suggested by the FSS estimate of KRW15.7
trillion in total credit exposures, the losses -- whatever
they ultimately measure -- from the Kumho Asiana restructuring
are likely to adversely and significantly impact the earnings or even
the capital levels of a few banks with larger exposures.
KDB has, as indicated, by far the largest exposure,
followed by Export-Import Bank of Korea and Woori Bank.
Moreover, KDB's financial burden could rise appreciably in
view of its plan to purchase a majority share of Daewoo Engineering and
Construction Co, a member of the group, at a significant premium
to market prices.
However, as mentioned, Moody's does not -- at this
point -- see any likely impact on the ratings of KDB or other rated
Korean banks. KDB's D BFSR -- or Ba2 baseline
credit assessment (BCA) -- already incorporates a certain
level of financial burden from its concentrated exposures to large corporate
groups overall. The bank's policy function --
as a lender to Korea's major corporates -- means that
it has traditionally played a leading role in the workouts of financially
troubled companies.
Rating actions in May 2009 -- in the wake of stress test applications
-- cover the levels of financial burden now evident at most Korean
banks. The actions, which involved 9 banks, included
downgrades of BFSRs and BCAs, and changes in BFSR outlooks.
For example, Moody's lowered Woori Bank's BCA to Baa2
from A3 due to its low capital level -- when compared to other banks
in the system -- and the possible emergence later on of
more serious asset quality problems.
For more details of Moody's stress test assumptions, see "Moody's
Approach to Estimating Korean Bank Credit Losses," September
2009.
Kumho Asiana announced a plan, which it had agreed with KDB,
to restructure its group companies due to financial problems on 30 December
2009.
According to the announcement, Keumho Industrial Co and Keumho Tire
Co will be subject to debt workout programs. Separately,
Kumho Petrochemical Co and Asiana Airlines Inc will seek to normalize
their operations on their own.
A private equity fund, led by KDB, will purchase 50%
plus 1 share of Daewoo Engineering and Construction Co. The group
will also try to sell some companies such as Kumho Life.
Kumho Asiana faces immediate financial problems primarily because of its
obligation to pay about KRW4 trillion by mid-January 2010 to investors
who partially financed the group's acquisition of Daewoo Engineering
and Construction Co in 2006.
These investors include some of its creditor banks and they also have
put options to force the group to buy back as much as about 39%
of Daewoo Engineering and Construction Co at KRW32,510 per share,
much higher than the December 30 closing of KRW12,800.
List bank ratings below:
Citibank Korea: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa2, local
currency deposit of A2, foreign currency long-term deposit
of A2;
Busan Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa1, local currency
deposit of A2, foreign currency long-term senior/subordinated
debt of A2/A3, foreign currency long-term deposit of A2;
Daegu Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa1, local currency
deposit of A2, foreign currency long-term senior/subordinated
debt of A2/A3, foreign currency long-term deposit of A2;
Export-Import Bank of Korea: BCA of A3, foreign currency
senior debt of A2;
Hana Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa1, local currency
deposit of A1, foreign currency long-term senior/subordinated
debt of A2/A2, foreign currency long-term deposit of A2;
Industrial Bank of Korea: BFSR of D+, BCA of Baa3,
foreign currency long-term senior/subordinated debt of A2/A2,
foreign currency long-term deposit of A2;
Jeonbuk Bank: BFSR of D+, BCA of Baa3, local currency
deposit of A3, foreign currency long-term deposit of A3;
Kookmin Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa1, local
currency deposit of A1, foreign currency long-term senior/subordinated
debt of A2/A2, foreign currency long-term deposit of A2;
Korea Exchange Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa2,
local currency deposit of A2, foreign currency long-term
senior/subordinated debt of A2/A3, foreign currency long-term
deposit of A2;
Korea Development Bank: BFSR of D, BCA of Ba2, local
currency deposit of A1, foreign currency long-term senior
debt and deposit of A2;
National Agricultural Cooperative Federation: BFSR of D+,
BCA of Ba1, local currency deposit of A1, foreign currency
long-term senior/subordinated debt of A2/A2, foreign currency
long-term deposit of A2;
Shinhan Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa1, foreign
currency long-term senior/subordinated debt of A2/A2, foreign
currency long-term deposit of A2;
Standard Chartered First Bank of Korea: BFSR of D+, BCA
of Baa3, local currency deposit of A2, foreign currency long-term
senior/subordinated debt of A2/A3, foreign currency long-term
deposit of A2;
Suhyup Bank: BFSR of D-, BCA of Ba3, local currency
deposit of A2, foreign currency long-term senior/subordinated
debt of A2/A3, foreign currency long-term deposit of A2;
Woori Bank: BFSR of C-, BCA of Baa2, foreign
currency long-term senior/subordinated debt of A2/A2, foreign
currency long-term deposit of A2;
Hong Kong
YoungIl Choi
Vice President - Senior Analyst
Financial Institutions Group
Moody's Asia Pacific Ltd.
JOURNALISTS: (852) 2916-1150
SUBSCRIBERS: (852) 3551-3077
Singapore
Beatrice Woo
VP - Senior Credit Officer
Financial Institutions Group
Moody's Singapore Pte Ltd.
JOURNALISTS: (852) 2916-1150
SUBSCRIBERS: (65) 6398-8308
Moody's says Korean banks likely unaffected by Kumho Asiana